Harvest, my favorite skill in the entire game and yet so boring!

So some people probably know me, some probably don’t.
Some know it some don’t, but Harvest is my favorite skill in the entire game.
https://imgur.com/3KvOrFK
My strongest character utilizes it and it’s capable of doing really cool and diverse stuff.
I am doing 400-500 corruption Monolith with ease and I am without any trying hard, under the top 10 Acolyte for SC Arena(Place 6 at the time of this Post to be exact). If i would not despise Arena that much, I guess I could make it under the top 3 with ease, but since the current Arena feels like a lottery I won’t even bother.

It has one of the oldest skill tree currently ingame and is still one of the first (if not the first?) skill that required you to combo with another skill to use it to it’s fullest potential, namely cursing a target, before hitting it with Harvest, to deal double damage.

It has something for almost everything:

  • Hit/Crit Damage
  • Ailments (Bleed/Poison)
  • Minions
  • Ward (it even can give your minions ward)

The only thing it does not offer, is variety in each of these branches, because depending on what you go, it’s very narrow in it’s applicable variety. Each branch is very small and you almost everytiem take the same stuff, depending on the fundamental buidl you are going for.

Today is the day, where I want to propose some stuff to make Harvest better.
I guess EHG wants to rework the skill spec tree entirely at some point, so probably most of my suggestiosn here will not make it into the skill spec tree, but hopefully I can give some inspiration.

First off, waht I like about Harvest and hopefully does not get changed:

  • Iron Mouth, huge Base Crit, for a very serious trade-off

https://imgur.com/sGbdcGW

  • Elements Of Death, all added damage converted to necrotic damage.
    This is very unique amogst Melee skills and makes it especially interesting, since Melee Necrotic Damage is not a stat, that you can acquire outside of Uniques and Lich Passives.

https://imgur.com/0DXKTVo
Those two nodes are very impactfull, especially for Hit/Crit builds and make Harvest very unique.

Fundamentelly what Harvest needs is:

  • More diversity and more nodes within each archtype/branch
  • More interesting interactions with different skills.
  • More effective more multiplier for it’s damage, it only truely has 2 more damage modifier nodes
  • Harvest does not have a single attack speed node in the entire tree.

Individual feedback on certain nodes:

https://imgur.com/P40tdG8
Symbol Of Loss: effectively the only true more multiplier in the entire tree, since the second one is a hybrid more multiplier that also effects minions and is quite useless for directly scaling Harvest’s damage. But its not even a true more multiplier, because its additive with the 100% mroe damage agaisnt cursed targets that Harvest inherently has!
This is a true point sink, which is very outaded for modern skill spec tree, spending 1/3 of your points into a single node is just not a good design.
Conditional modifiers are usually around 15-20% more damage/point, since Harvest already incentives cursing the Target, it’s also quite boring here, but still fitting.
Make it 0/3 with 20% more damage

https://imgur.com/yR5moli
Learned Weakness: simply to weak, even for a global buff. I do like things that globally buff your character, to incentives combining it with other stuff, but also 5 point node is too much, change it to 0/2 or 0/3 with like 20-25% crit chance.

https://imgur.com/SyWT2xQ
Double Edged-Scythe: One of the coolest nodes in the tree, as I already mentioned, I really do like trade-off nodes.
The following issue is not something related to Harvest, but a general itemization thing.
There is literally one single way- to coutneract self-bleed currently, which is one specific Item. (Namely Exsanguinous).
Acolyte has another source of self-bleed affliction; Spirit plague.
Giving us more options to play around that would certainly help with build variety, to utilize these nodes. Especially because Exsanguinous forces you into a very specific playstyle, making other playstyle not compatible with it.

https://imgur.com/ofjFCkF
Blood Sculptor: Very cool node, if you wanna go the hybrid Self/Minion Damage Route, but when your builds heavily leans towards minions and you just want to support them, it makes this nodes very hard to use, since you actually need to deal the killing blow.
Change it so it’s enemies die within 1-2 seconds being damage by Harvest have a chance to summon a Blood Spectre.

New Node Suggestions:

Key Nodes

  • Sow and Reap: Harvest deals x% more damage for 4 seconds, after manually casting a curse.
    This would incentive a more active playstyle, not using any source of auto-proccing curses on the target
  • Frenzied Harvest: Gains 1% Attack Speed on hit for 4 seconds, stacks 50 times (each stack has it’s own individual timer)
  • Rich Harvest: Harvest deals more melee damage per ailment on a target, up to a maximum of 5/10/15/20
  • Exorcising Reaping: Harvest does consume all stacks of Damned on the target to deal x% more melee damage. (Damned stacks consumed that way, will not deal their remaining damage)
  • Hollow Harvest: Harvest and all ailments applied by it cannot leech any damage as health. Harvest deals x% mroe damage per y% leech it would have had.
  • Invigorating Rituals: Harvest increases your Health Regen by 1 per target hit: Stacks 50 Times, Lasts 4 seconds
  • Straining Swings: Harvest cost +2/4/6/8 Mana, but deals 25/50/75/100% more damage

Minor Nodes

  • Attack Speed
  • Damned Chance
  • Melee Leech
  • %inc. Health Regen, after hitting with Harvest for 4 seconds

Obviously all hard numbers provided here are subjectve to change for balancing and depending on the context they would be applied in.

All in all I want to wrap this up, by saying: Harvest is not in a bad spot right now, it just lacks the diversity other similar skills have.

Also, when Warlock will be released, I can’t wait for all the new curses and which build opportunities this might bring for any Harvest Build, since I assume Warlock will at least bring 1 or 2 new curses.

Also I did not suggest any minion related nodes, since I think I am not in a good spot to provide any minions related suggestions.

Thanks for anybody reading all of thise and I am eagerly to hear about how other people think about Harvest, since I know it’s a pretty unpopular skill.

8 Likes

First of all: What you said pretty much.

So I don’t want to go deep into “Do this and that!” but rather voice me feelings toward the skill.

  1. Zero interactions aka curse and enemy then press rightclick
  2. Int scaling for melee necrotic dmg is neat but even with 100+ int the dmg is only okayish while in theory you wear another 2handen weapon worth of flat dmg
  3. Bad scaling from in tree nodes… no attack speed for example
  4. Far to easy to reach 100% crit chance but on the other hand the crit chance is pretty much needed to do at least okayish dmg
  5. No real interactions from other skill trees for Harvest

Harvest is an effective skill, the build is brainnumbing easy to play and with all the leech Lich offeres very effective. For me it suffers the same problem Swipe has. The skill is okay but braindead. just hold it down and use another skill from time to time.

I like to play the harvest Lich because it’s on the “turn brain partly off” scaling of builds but then again I play WW Barb in D3 ^^.

This topic was automatically closed 60 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.