I feel like this is a discussion that has happened many, many times throughout the years.
And I get it! It feels good when a dev team is interested in player feedback, and even better when they act on it.
But I think it’s been fairly well-established that it doesn’t usually end well.
- The “community” that the devs hear from is far from the entirety of the actual playerbase. The vast majority of players in these games don’t bother with the forums or discord. Sure, they might stop by once in a while. They might have joined the discord to see news once in a while. But they aren’t the players that are providing feedback to the devs. The ones who are are the ones who yell the most about it and make the biggest scene. This includes streamers, who are well-known for their ability to make a big scene. For reference, at the time of posting only about 250 people have engaged with this thread.
I’d be very interested to know how many responses EHG got on the survey. I wonder how it would compare to the estimated million that have bought the game. 1%? 5%?
- You allude to this in your post: Players don’t always know what they want. We don’t have nearly as much information available to us as the development team does. We don’t know the true intent behind all of the decisions that have been made to make the game what it is. We don’t know what the roadmap is for the years to come. We don’t know what balance changes the dev team is working on for next cycle.
They do. Trust them.
- I don’t know if you’ve studied developmental psychology before, but what happens from here is pure operant conditioning theory. Loud and outspoken players communicate to the devs (many in a very negative fashion) what they want to see in the game. The devs acquiesce, reinforcing the behavior of the loud and outspoken players. The loud and outspoken players get LOUDER and MORE OUTSPOKEN the next time they see something they don’t like.
It doesn’t take long until the devs lose control of their game, lest they incur the wrath of the EXTREMELY LOUD and EXTREMELY OUTSPOKEN players.
At the end of the day, EHG has created the game we’re so passionate about. Let them continue to refine it.