First off:
I do fully understand why they did this change and it was inevitable.
But i already suggested on multiple occasions that Reap also needs some alternative functionality (through skill nodes within Reaper Form)
I think if they would be a ndoe in Reaper Form, that makes Reap into a pure damage ability, I my posted link the suggestign was a Spin/circle Attack, but it could also be a Cone.
Think of a pimped up version of harvest with a 2-3 second cooldown with appropiate damage and maybe even more health/ward on hit.
IMO Tis would be the easiest short term solution, until Reaper Form get’s a compeltely overhaul in the future.
What bogs me the most about this change: I do not choose Reaper Form, because of Reap, but because Reaper Form is so stong.
But this essentially now gives me a dead skill slot in alot of situations.
Even with shared cooldown reap sitll has some occasions where it’s stronger, because it is faster executed (if you don’t have cast speed).
But overall Transplant is superior in almost any way.