Getting this out of the way first: I know these are not season mechanics but core. Treat it as season-introduced mechanics if you will.
I feel like all the season mechanics (2 exceptions see table below) lack depth and therefor so also does the entire endgame. They don’t allow for much player agency, they don’t let us device different strategies, have different mechanics interact, or truely juice them for really hard but rewarding self-controlled content. You can’t “sink your teeth” into a mechanic. The only real “juicing” we can do is corruption pushing and that has become so mundane over the last 2 years. I fear EHG thinks introducing corruption tiers will save the endgame - I currently imagine it to be similar to Diablo style tiers. It solves a few problems sure, such as feeling a difference between the tiers, more clearly outlined difficulty and rewards, goalposts / milestones and getting rid of the honestly numbing and braindead pushing beyond 1k corruption with endless corruption scheme (hopefully it *remains* capped at the 11th tier). But the mechanics would remain shallow unfortunately: They are like ladders you climb simply by doing them. A progress bar fills up or a number increases. The rewards are also pretty much just static and you simply farm them while praying to the RNG gods. You can’t influence them otherwise.
| Season | Mechanic | Reward | Issue |
|---|---|---|---|
| S1 | Harbingers | Harbinger items, fringe use | Do all 10 once, fill Forgotten Knights faction bar. Done. |
| S1 | Nemesis | Nemesis Egg unique items for LP chance. Multi T7 exalted items pre-S5 |
Difficulty tied to corruption, reward is not. No "juicing". No strategy, only RNG. |
| S2 | Weaver Tree | Juice! (And Imprints.) | This is a good one. Not many issues here, except players probably take similar nodes. |
| S2 | Woven Echos | Juice! (And Bosses and Crafting etc.) | A glimps what could have been, because here players could device their own strategies. Unfortunately it mostly boils down to Lost Folly + Temple or Trove. Most Woven Echoes are done just once for points. Only Lost Folly aura is really all that "strategic". |
| S2 | Tombs and Cemeteries | Weaver Idols, WW items, Idol enchanting. | Difficulty tied to corruption. Hard RNG on getting good idols and rerolling them. No player influence. |
| S3 | Rift Beast | Primordial Item or Rune of Evolution | This could have been so much more, but it turned out flat. 7 evolutions of the beast max. and it resets. The evolutions don't matter. The evolution rewards hardly matter and just to farm a non-tangible currency. RNG to re-roll the Primordial item you need or farm the RoE. Once you got an acceptable Primordial, your done. No strategy. |
| S4 | Omen Window | Rune of Corruption, Altars?, Omen Idols? (Pre-corrupted items) |
3 tiers. No strategy. Basically for farming RoC. Good Altars and Omen Idols are rare and RNG. No strategy and player influence. Pre-corrupted items sold as "reward" makes me mad. |
| S4 | Echo Chains | Alternative inefficient farming? | I don't get them. I don't do them. I want to disable them. |
| S5 | Rage of Morditas | Rings, Gloves, Multi T6 and T7 items. Uniques. | Get 5/5 by killing monsters. Fill a progress bar (hidden in Nexus)? 4/4 WT node, but capped. There's no real strategy. Just do them and pray to RNG gods. |
Comparing that to the mechanics in PoE 1 and 2 and TLI where you build up and focus on one mechanic over multiple maps and play sessions to get most out of it, with a lot of different strategies involved.
Edit: Considerations to salvage the existing mechanics or for new mechanics:
- Don’t solely rely on corruption (tiers) to increase difficulty + reward. The mechanics itself or interaction with other systems should allow us to come up with clever strategies to maximize it.
- Don’t just allow us to increase frequency but difficulty and equally rewards: Move frequency into (potentially mutually exclusive) Weaver Tree nodes. E.g. rework Aura woven echoes to juice a mechanic, especially if multiple overlap onto an adjacent map. Woven echoes such as Nesting Grove (and many other Woven echoes) are pointless, because the mechanics they support are already so abundant in regular mapping.
- Give rewards that matter: Introduce something that is scarce and sought after. Fricition makes things interesting. Eventhough it might seem painful at first and challenging to balance right (see imprint nerfs). Don’t regard pre-corrupted items, pre-sealed items, pre-primordialed items as rewards. Having exalted items drop as such is a punishment rather than a reward. Affix shards are so abundant that they also don’t count as rewards, so are most glyphs and runes after a short while.
- Procedural generated levels are not a silver-bullet.
Cave or tombs/cemeteries are not automatically interesting just by being procedurally generated. The goal both of these levels remains to get to the end as quickly as possible. Exploration is not incentivised. - Multi-stage mechanics across multiple maps and play sessions to allow for clever strategies to emerge.
Rift Beast are theoretically multi-stage, but the lineage and evolution reset are capped too low and there’s no meaningful reward. Neither does it matter what evolution of the beast is chosen. We don’t even look at them when choosing one of the three. The different currencies are just stepping-stones to get a lottery ticket and feel like artificial friction. It’s not interesting farm x amount of fangs or petals or whatever for the arbitrary prices. - Being better at a higher difficulty mechanic and having skill should be rewarded compared to just repeating them more often on lower difficulty.
Rage of Morditas simply has a progress bar that is capped (hidden in Nexus screen). There are three endlessly repeating and resetting echoes in Nexus screen with capped (?) easy difficulty with no actual reward except having more shots at the lottery in one go without having to do the full mechanics again. Having more Rage charges doesn’t increase the reward. Gathering more blood does nothing, it’s just a reset the three echoes over and over again. This is not exciting and not innovative. - Overly frequent occurrence makes things boring and annoying, especially when they are not all that rewarding: Got over your Loot Lizard obsession.