Make a Paladin unique with a mod that bars the player from wearing corrupted items

It just occurred to me that thematically Paladins probably shouldn’t be wearing corrupted items. I suspect you won’t be able to do it though because Paladin’s a subclass, not a class. But maybe there’s some way to do it where the mod says you can’t wear corrupted items if you have Judgement or Symbols of Hope unlocked?

1 Like

What would be the upside? You’re giving up a big source of power, so you need to have a big source of power to compensate.

Besides, if all you want is theming, then you can just add an affix that turns all corrupted items into sanctified ones. It would work just the same, except you’d get a different name and a different colour. No need to restrict anything.

1 Like

Is the Paladin so underpowered that it needs moar powah?

1 Like

No, but if you make a unique that only gives you downsides, why would you use it? :stuck_out_tongue:

3 Likes

I’ll leave that up to them to decide, however I will say your comment does raise the possibility that they could later introduce a mechanic where items receive blessings, and they could make it such that players can’t wear both Blessed and Corrupted items.

It also just occurred to me that instead of it being a unique item EHG could make it a node in the Paladin passive tree where selecting that node unlocks the ability to access other nodes that give buffs that offset the choice. Doing it this way would remove the need for the unique item to track subclass.

I could see that, but I think I’d rather see it as a unique than the passive tree. Otherwise, if you do decide that corrupted items are worth it, you’ll be left with less nodes to choose from.

A unique could provide an upside to it. I asked because you might already have an idea in mind.

A cool idea, I think, is to make it dependent on corrupted items. Something like:

-Your corrupted items become sanctified.

-Sanctified items lose their corrupted affix.

-You get 5% more damage per sanctified item.

-This item can’t be corrupted.

Those could be feasible items, but wouldn’t do anything to address the element that Paladins thematically shouldn’t be wearing corrupted equipment.

It would mean they’re cleaning the corruptions, which would be thematically appropriate.

The existence of X is not the same thing as saying you can’t use Y.

Well, I suggested that because that would allow you to create a benefit that scales from corrupted (now sanctified) items. It seemed to fit thematically because you’re cleansing the corruption.

You could just forbid using them and give a flat %more damage, but not using “bad things” seems too little for a paladin theme. They see “bad things” and want to turn them into “good things” (or dead things, when that fails :laughing:). That was the reasoning behind my suggestion.

Maybe different role playing settings have different rules for paladins, and I’m not claiming to be an expert, but my understanding has always been that paladins are simply so devout that they’d refuse to accept a corrupted item outright. There would never be a situation where a paladin would ever say, “Well, this corrupted item has better stats that this blessed item, so I guess I’ll wear the corrupted item.” The benefits or sacrifices don’t even enter into it.

Now, separate from that, if there were blessed items that the paladins could use then there also doesn’t need to be any benefit given in exchange for them not being able to use corrupted items. The mods lost from not being able to access the corrupted items would be replaced by access to the mods on the blessed items.

But as I said, the existence of blessed items alone is not the same thing as having the game mechanically block paladins from using corrupted gear, so to me these are two separate conversations - one is the mechanic that blocks them, and then the other conversation is whether or not there’s anything that replaces these items or makes up for the subclass not being able to use them.

Of course EHG could also flip it. They could make it such that accepting the paladin mastery locks a player out of using corrupted items, but then give them a passive tree node that allows paladins to opt IN to wearing them, with some added stats. They could role play it by saying something along the lines that with this node paladins are kind of self-flagellating … they allow themselves to wear corrupted gear, but it makes them so angry that they get some buff out of it.

It could be one of those nodes that you can put multiple points into, one point for each piece of corrupted gear, with some buff that doesn’t scale with points allocated but requires a certain minimum investment. That way they’d be limited to maybe 4-8 corrupted items but the passive node buff could make up for the fact that they can’t wear as many as other builds (since it would also preclude them from wearing corrupted idols).

From most classic paladin literature (including D&D), a paladin seeing a corrupted (thus, evil) item would want to purge the land from it. So they would either sanctify the item so that it now gives a blessing, or they would outright destroy it. Paladins are zealots. They wouldn’t just leave a corrupted item be for someone else to use.

That was why I suggested changing the corrupted items to sanctified ones. They don’t need to give a blessing (after all, I did say they lose their corrupted affixes), but they’re no longer evil. They’re now blessed by the deity.

The whole problem with that is that those nodes would have to be VERY good. Not only are you sacrificing a lot of power from the corrupted items, you also have to sacrifice passive points to get those nodes, thus not getting other good nodes that players with corruptions will get.

While I agree about making up for the passive point opportunity costs, I’m not so sure about just how powerful the node’s benefit would need to be related to replacing the benefits of the corrupted affixes, especially if blessed items also exist that the paladin could wear.

If there are blessed items that have a rough equivalent power level (just with different affixes that a paladin or other players might want) then the passive node would only really be letting the paladin swap 4-8 blessed items for 4-8 corrupted items (to maybe get access to some interesting corrupted affixes) while the paladin could still have every other item of theirs be blessed.

In fact, in that case the node’s buff might also not need to be as strong because the corrupted affixes they want might be what gives them some benefit. If X and Y are roughly equivalent then the node might not need to give as much of a benefit, except to cover the opportunity costs.

Why would they waste time creating a mechanic that does the same thing as corruption, though? Just to create flavour for the paladin? Not only that, it would be competing with corruption, since you either have one or the other. So either they’re extremely well balanced (unlikely, as we’ve seen so far) or one would effectively replace the other making it obsolete.

Also, why do you keep saying 4-8? There are 11 gear slots, plus however many idols you use, plus the altar, all of which can be corrupted. I’d say on average you’ll have access to 20-ish corruption slots. That’s a lot of power to give up on.

It occurred to me that, in that case, Void Knights should benefit from wearing corrupted items… oh, wait.
Actually, that’s a really great idea, and you’re likely right. We’ll eventually have a “consecration/blessing” mechanic, which might make those passive nodes more valuable. Though, rather than being part of the standard passive tree, this could function as a general talent tree shared across all classes—where you’d earn one point every 10 levels (roughly) to spend on things like increased movement speed, flat damage bonuses, and so on.
Thematically, you’re spot on; it also makes perfect sense that a Mage would gain more bonuses from a staff, scepter, or wand. That said, even if the development team were to implement your idea, the actual effect would likely be very minor—much like how, in the past, a Paladin could occasionally cheat death.

Oh, I don’t know, why bother having any leagues past LEO? I didn’t say this could only be used by the paladin, or that it’s only for the paladin. I just said that thematically, if given a choice, paladins wouldn’t even consider it a choice.

3-5 is usually how many points go into those ‘does not scale with points’ buffs on passive tree nodes, with 8 usually being the max number of points you can put into a node (I know there are a few exceptions).

I’ve already agreed that it would probably be too difficult to balance giving up corrupted items with just passive tree nodes or item affixes. If they ever do implement something like blessed items then they wouldn’t be giving up any slots. They’d only be using a proposed node to allow them to use corrupted items in a few of them instead of blessed items.

In any case, this isn’t a major proposal. It’s not like I’m saying they should put this in any time soon, or even ever. The thematic thing occurred to me, and that’s lead to some interesting ideas, but compared with some of the other suggestions we’ve all made this is pretty low on the totem pole. I’d be fine if they never implement it, but I could see it being feasible, if done right, at some point.

I didn’t say creating a new mechanic is a waste of time. I said (which you clipped out of context, for some reason) that it’s a waste of time to create a new mechanic **that does the exact same thing as a mechanic that is already in the game**.

Not only that, it’s directly competing with said mechanic. So you either balance it just right (which, let’s be honest, EHG doesn’t have a good track record of) or one of them will become useless.

So you’re wasting time creating a new mechanic that is a copy of an existing one and in the end you’ll likely only end up using one of them anyway. There is no point in that.

Yes, and I said that, thematically, a paladin would want to purge the corruption, either by sanctifying it, or by destroying the “evil” item, so as not to tempt anyone else.

Paladins are zealots that fight evil. They’re not just beat cops that avoid jaywalking.