Boss ward issue

The TLDR; if you don’t play a build that does massive damage the boss ward current system is bad for most builds.

I’m going to use a very specific example that i tested and retested to make sure it wasn’t a one off before i made this post. It involves the new pin boss and is by no means a complaint about that specific fight or its balance. It was just a controlled testing ground i could easily recreate the system to gather “my data”. This is also not a complaint that my build doesn’t do enough damage or other builds do to much data.

This post is all feedback on the current state of boss ward and its negative situation if you are not able to either “chunk” the boss hp or straight up 1shot the boss.

The test was done in 453 corruption in the woven echo Demigods ascendance.
This is all personal opinion do what u want with it.
the build used can be seen here https://www.lastepochtools.com/profile/legionone/character/legionthree

So as it stands i reliably take the boss down from 100% hp to 80% hp within 20-30 seconds. Which is reasonable and not an issue. Now the issue starts once the 1st threshold for the boss ward is hit and protects the boss hp.
Once the boss ward becomes active my damage amount does not change and as far as i know there are no added defensive changes just a system that gives the round about system that gives the boss more HP just in a different form.

Now for one bar of boss ward the time to deplete the bar with my damage and the wards natural boss ward degradation takes around 2mines to be completely depleted. And this time is consistent through multiple testing with no changes to build or fight.
As far as i can remember when the change to boss hp to the incorporation of boss ward phases, it was introduced as a means to balance the fight and slow down players and ideally prevent 1 shotting the boss’s. Basically trying to make boss fights last longer and be more impactful. Which is fine if the system was balanced and appropriately scaled to different damage ranges.
As far as i can tell the ward was degrading at a rate of 1% of total ward % per second with no ramp up of degradation as the fight dragged on. This degradation rate was also with the same damage that took the boss 1st chunk of natural hp down “fast”.

So if i sum all this up into a general statement it would go as follows; Currently boss ward does almost nothing to slow down the “strong” skills/builds. And has just created a situation where builds that could be considered “weak” by comparisons are the hindered and indirectly made worse.

IM not here to provide a suggestion on any changes or fixes, i just want this situation to be present and hopefully looked at for rebalancing considerations.

To be clear I’m not asking for any damage buffs or nerfs to any skill build or mob. This is all about the boss ward system. And how i believe it is not in a good state when looked at on its overall impact. I’m not trying to argue anything this is just my personal experience opinion and feedback.

1 Like

That was recently discussed in this thread.

In general, boss ward isn’t well balanced. There are several ways it could be improved. It’s better than the previous DR system in that it’s at least visible to the players, but not only doesn’t it stop broken builds from one shotting bosses, it also doesn’t help low DPS builds because the ward decay is too slow.

2 Likes

It’s also better for lower dps builds than just adding the additional ward as hp because the ward decays (as all ward does) so lower dps builds have more time for the ward to decay rather than having to chew through the whole bar which is what hugh dps builds have to do.

It’s not perfect & if builds were “reasonably” balanced then it wouldn’t be necessary.

That’s not how it works.

1 Like

again this is just feedback and personal experience example provided why i believe said feedback. There is no suggestion box or feedback inbox i can provide this too what i have access to. So i put it here.

cool, I’m not here to argue this or that. this is a “controlled test” i could do and a provided example with personal experience and opinion.

I agree with that. But you said

And I was pointing out that it was already recently been brought to attention again.

That’s fine, but from the statement I quoted it appears that your opinion is based on a misunderstanding. Boss ward is only worse for low dps builds compared to no-boss-ward-&-no-extra-hp which isn’t, IMO, a reasonable comparison.

I definitely agree that it feels bad to be steadily getting through a boss’ red hp bar only to be confronted by a brand new blue hp bar & then this happens several times.

I’m not saying that this is the least worst possible option, but it is the least worse option that they’ve tried thus far. But if there’s a better way of solving the problem of high dps builds ignoring boss mechanics (outisde of having reasonable build balancing, which is a far bigger problem), then I’m sure everyone would be all ears.

not the point, if i was to provide a possible change it would either be increased ward degen rate, or boss’s ward is a set time thing and not an amount (that way u can still damage it and leech to survive while boss is not ripping). Lets say each threshold trigger sets a 10 second “sudo-inv stage” where boss takes dam but hp % doesn’t lower. And that way they can slow down the big hitters while low hitters have equal “neg impact”. That would be my 2 bits of thought’s but its not about that.

Compared to DR? It absolutely is the case.

Low DPS builds have been significantly slowed in beating bosses while high dps ones were mildly slowed or even sped up, depending on how far along you got before until the DR kicked in.

But I’ve stated it before when the system went live… it did the exact counter of what the DR system was designed to do, which is giving low dps builds a catchup mechanic by hindering higher DPS ones to simply burst the boss away in seconds.
The overall damage potential of builds just outperformed so substantially that the whole system could be sidestepped entirely.

Kinda. Lower dps builds wouldn’t be able to stack multiple stacks of boss DR because they would be less likely to hit the next threshold before the current/previous stack timed out. Higher dps builds would stack multiple layers of the boss DR because they hit subsequent thresholds very quickly so they caused the boss to have relatively high DR. Players of said high dps builds bitched about this feeling bad (fair) so EHG tried to come up with another way round the lack of balance that resulted in such a high disparity in boss kill times.

I want to say that they’ve tried to rebalance the boss ward by speeding up the degen but I can’t be arsed to fing out which patch that was in.

This is what the high dps builds experienced. They didn’t like it.

Yup. Because the disparity between the really high dps & low dps builds is waaaaaaaay too big. If the damage range was smaller then they wouldn’t need DR or ward unless it was an intended mechanic.

1 Like

IMO and TBH I don’t think things like these features and/or changes to features care much about, or at all about how much players like it. It’s more so about the blanket term “overall game balancing” which aka means (and this is all opinion and no factual statements from devs that I know about confirm this. It is all my personal impressions) making player suck (aka easier to kill and less dmg out put). I personally don’t believe features like this are made to increase the player positive experience but are more so about making player struggle more. And in this particular case is the good old tried and true answer to “how do we make boss fights harder”. And the broken old scape goat of “let’s just give it more hp” won on how to answer. Again this is just the rambling of a salty old guy. As players seem (to me) to be resistant to innovative ideas or different ways to make boss fights harder. Easiest example would be puzzle anything added to the boss fight.

If players (most not necessarily all) didn’t enjoy face rolling all content then build that do damage in the millions like ES wouldn’t be the top played build every league. You can argue all you want and I don’t deny every player doesn’t just enjoy 1 shotting everything, but the data every season shows an alarming amount of the player base play within 3-4 builds.

So yeah I believe that things like boss ward are not (solely) about balance but are more about stretching out limited content and availability of acceptable changes. That won’t start a French Revolution calling for the end of heads because a game changed.

Sorry about that off topic tangent, I started typing a response triggered so salt one thing lead to another and bing bang bong u got what I wrote.

Again at the end of the day this is still a business that has to pay its employees. Not ever decision will be made “for the best of the community”, as without funds to pay to keep the servers online and the $$$ to incentivize the programmers to not stay home and come back in the next day.

Sorry side track again imma stop here and for some reason hit post vs the delete button.

1 Like

I’m not quite sure what you mean here, but enough of the playerbase was vocal about it & the devs evidently did care about that enough to change it (whether that was successful or not is a different kettle of fish).

There is overlap between those two things. The devs want to make bosses with interesting mechanics that players enjoy rather than ignore because their characters have so much dps that they can kill the boss so quickly they don’t get to experience said mechanics. Ditto the player being tanky enough to ignore any mechanics & just facetank everything. So the player having some level of struggle or difficulty but then succeeding is a positive experience. The other end of the scale has bosses that are so difficult that they always kill the player & bosses that are so easy that they have all the joy of the training dummy… All of this is only really possible if builds are broadly comparable in terms of damage output which is not the case at the moment & leads to bandaid fixes such as the boss DR/ward.

Ultimately yes. Though at least the blue hp decays & I believe that this is most of the total hp the boss has. It is a totally reasonable question to ask about whether it decays fast enough.
But in the absence of even slightly functional balance this is the situation we have ourselves in.

Yup.

Absolutely!

You might be right there with it not solely being a balancing act but instead something to stretch out the gameplay existing.

But plainly spoken, that’s the ‘modern overstepping’ of developers if that’s the case.
Cannot make a compelling experience so instead it’s made into a chore which kinda keeps you engaged nonetheless.

EIther/or, if it’s by design or incompetence in that regard… both lead to the same outcome, which we can see. And that’s a dwindling playerbase as the range of choice on the market is too large as to keep people hooked this way, they got alternatives nowadays, so they’re only shooting themselves in their own foot with it.
People just move to greener pastures since they exist.

Which is simply EHG’s major issue… balance.

To allow designing a compelling boss you need to keep builds overall in the range where neither overpowering nor neutralizing it without excessive investment (which is another portion of balancing, to allow it to happen as the absolute end-goal).
Otherwise we see what we do see… bandaid measures to ‘fix’ something rather then tackling the root cause itself. And if nothing is done it’s even worse experience-wise.

One thing I cannot agree with either of you both here is that players are resistant to innovative ideas.
It’s the contrary… but we don’t see a lot of innovation happening.
What we see instead is re-inventing the wheel from scratch and then being all surprised when players don’t want to deal with that mess.

We see actual innovation done with the loot filter for example, having it in a sort of ‘block’ building mechanic in-game rather then meddling about outside of it, which is well received.
But that mechanic is not fully fleshed out yet because of the limitation for how many rules can be made, if that’s increased and stays performant then it’s a fantastic inclusion which future games will have to copy to be competitive… but since the limitation is because of performance issues it’s for the moment still half-baked.

It’s like a new invention which solves problems… like… solid state batteries. Great idea! Not economical yet and hence nobody uses it obviously. Introducing problems already solved with other batteries and hence simply not used until the upsides are bigger then the downsides.
Same with the loot filter in LE, the downside is how detailed you can make it, which forces you to either have a overly generic filter or one focused on your played character itself. If that’s solved then we’ll see ‘universal’ filters which are top-tier coming up and 99% of the ones we currently have being thrown out the window.
But it’s not ‘there’ yet.

1 Like

I’m not sure.

I got divorced ~2 years ago for a variety of reasons, but if you’d listened to my ex-wife early on it was solely to get some (it wasn’t). Things like this can reflect more on the observer (us) than the devs sometimes.

Ultimately yes, the why doesn’t really matter.

Yup.

I never said they were.

1 Like

The 2 main issues players had with it were:

1- It wasn’t transparent. You would be doing a lot of damage and suddenly you do a trickle of it without any way of knowing why it was happening.

2- Leech builds were suddenly extremely vulnerable because they didn’t deal enough damage to continue leeching, so they died.

Boss ward was created to fix these 2 issues. Players clearly see what’s happening and both your damage and leech remain constant. The problem is that it doesn’t really address the issue of high DPS builds bypassing mechanics nor does it address the issue of low DPS builds which now have to deal way more damage than before.

There are fixes to this. A “simple” way to fix it would be:

-Increase the ward “hp” and massively increase the ward decay, so that each ward phase lasts 5s at most.

-Change the ward thresholds to also decay with time. Meaning that a low DPS build that takes 20s (or however much becomes balanced) to reach the first threshold doesn’t actually trigger ward.

This would make it so that high DPS builds would have to deal 10x more damage than before, but low DPS builds would only have to deal the normal hp damage. Also, the builds that just about trigger ward but don’t have enough damage to damage all the ward would see it go away much faster, whereas high DPS builds would simply deal the full damage.

There are probably other ways to balance this, but one of them should be implemented, because currently it’s unbalanced. Not only doesn’t it stop high DPS builds from one shotting ubers, it doesn’t help low DPS builds either.

3 Likes

I think they should make the boss some kind of pseudo invincible state on ward phase.
Like still let player deal damage and leeching and stack their damage mechanic… but make the boss regain same amount of ward.
Then the ward is decay in 10s (or some more suitable number, 100 is too much for a fight, as the dev want player “play the boss mechanic”).

This way the high dps cannot delete the boss fast enough and cannot skip boss mechanic, and the lower dps do not have to really do 10x more damage

Offt big thread and as usual I skipped most of it - I personally have hated ward since I started playing this game I always just feel the boss should just have giga HP and no ward so you have to burn him down regardless.

I think it’s silly you can bypass ward as well with stun mechanics - example being normal Abby using my WP last season who did insane damage if I went in normal it would hit him, ward would kick in and he would take 20+ seconds. If I put on stun blessing from Lagon and add a stun idol he would die in 4 seconds. To me as a gamer that makes no sense.

Bosses are bosses. I’m ok with a “shield” phase where they block all damage and you have to maybe kill adds or avoid some kind of mechanic but the way it is in LE is sloppy as heck.

I also find regen phases a really lazy addition to big fights. Put some thought into it - instead of regen kick him into some sort of frenzy’d state where he still has the low hp but gallops round doing crazy kicks, I dont know anything but regen. The regen phase is also weird because he goes back to 60% hp but then gets 1 shot right after? It’s all very confusing and I really don’t want to hear someone on here try explain it. I’m just saying I agree with OP.

Ward sucks. Fights are sloppy.

1 Like